Archived: DAWG Index V2, retired Oct. 2026. These grades used the old five-part formula. Current DAWG Index →

DAWG Index

Who gets up for big games, and who shrinks.

Vegas sets the bar for every game. We grade who cleared it.

This Week

The week's biggest stages, ranked. Each team's rank is where it stands at living up to expectations this season, out of every Power 4 team. Green top third · gold middle · red bottom third.

Every game is graded Sunday. Then come back to see who showed up.

Compare Two Teams

Side by side this season. No predictions, just how each has played.
vs

Green marks the better side. Everything here describes how each team has played this season; none of it predicts the game.

Matchup Builder

Vegas line, adjusted for how each team handles this kind of environment. A scenario tool, not a pick: tested on 2022–25 games, the adjusted line beat the spread 50% of the time.

Blank = use this season's betting ratings. Negative spread = home team favored.

How It Could Go
How We Got This Line
What is this?

Vegas sets the bar for every game. We grade who cleared it.

  1. What it is. Every Power 4 game is graded on how each team played against the Vegas line. A team's DAWG score is its average grade. 0 = exactly what Vegas expected · +3 or better = DAWG · −3 or worse = SOFT
  2. Why it matters. A record says who won. This says who beat expectations, factoring in the pressure of the game: who shows up when it counts, and who only beats cupcakes.
  3. Why trust it. Every Power 4 game since 2019, every grade public, and we show what holds up and what doesn't.

Where does your team rank?

Highlights

Grades: 0 = played like Vegas expected · +5 = better than 84% of Power 4 performances since 2019 · +10 = better than 96%

DAWG Rankings

Hover a header for its meaning · tap to sortTap a header to sort · tap a team for its page

Season grade = average game grade. +3 or better = DAWG · −3 or worse = SOFT · 0 = played like Vegas expected

#TeamConfW–L

Big Games vs. Routine Games

This season so far. Right = better than expected in routine games · Up = better in big games

Swipe the chart sideways to see every team →

Poll Check

AP rank next to DAWG rank: where each team ranks at living up to expectations, out of every Power 4 team.

Earned it ranked and a top-12 DAWG team · Fraud Watch ranked, but bottom half or winning on luck · Sleeper unranked, but a top-15 DAWG team

AP RankAPTeamW–LDAWG RankDAWGSeason GradeLuckVerdict

Due for a Correction

Records running ahead of, or behind, how teams actually played, judged play by play.

Running hot

Record better than the play

Running cold

Record worse than the play

Biggest Blown Leads

This season · the biggest leads that still turned into losses
TeamGameLed byFinal

Top 10 Games

Single-game grade

The best single games of the season. Tougher settings (road, night, a packed stadium, a ranked opponent) raise the grade. Tap a game to see how it graded.

#TeamGameScoreSpreadHindsight SpreadGame GradeHindsight Grade

Conferences

Is the conference actually better, or just louder?

Results: Power 4 teams playing Power 4 teams from other conferences (nonconference games, bowls, the playoff). Expectations: how each conference's teams have played against what was expected. A conference can win head to head and still sit near zero on expectations, because Vegas already expects it to win.

ConferenceSince 2019Avg marginVs VegasWinning yearsThis yearMargin

Results: head to head, 2019 to now

Against expectations, this season

Average season grade of each conference's teams · tap a conference to filter the chart below

#ConferenceTeamsDAWGBig GamesRoutineBig vs. RoutineDawgs · Soft

Year by year

Season DAWG Big-Game DAWG Current Coach's Tenure

OpponentScoreGame GradeDate · SiteStageLinevs Spreadexcl. garbage timeFinishingKnife TwistCash-InAnswersStarting QB

Tap a game for the full breakdown: spread, finishing, knife twist, cash-in, answers.

Biggest Wins Since 2019

Wins in big games, ranked by how big the game was. The grade shows how well they actually played.

GameDateScoreStageGame Grade

Best Performances Since 2019

GameDateScoreGame Grade

Worst Performances Since 2019

GameDateScoreGame Grade

Coaches

How each coach's teams have done against expectations since 2019

A track record, not a prediction. It measures expectations, not wins.

CoachSchoolAt School SinceSeasonsRecord By season

Quarterbacks

Points per game each QB adds compared with an average Power 4 QB

Every pass, sack, run and turnover counts, adjusted for the defense he faced. Unlike team scores, this one sticks from year to year, even after a transfer.

#QB
Loading quarterbacks…

Rating pulls small samples toward average; Raw is the number with no pulling. Tap a QB for his year-by-year line, big games and game log. This season needs 3+ starts; career needs 10+.

Team Tendencies

Season projection · through Week 5 · hover a header for its formula · tap to sort

The game grade tells you how a team played. These are habits that tend to stick from one year to the next, so they say more about how a team will play. Early in the season each number leans on last year (less so with a new coach) and moves as this season's games come in.

#TeamConf

Trackers

2026 season · through Week 5 · hover a header for its formula · tap to sort

Who lets games get away after building a lead, and who makes it count when the defense gets a stop.

Blown Leads

Team

Cash-In After Stops

Team

How the Grade Works

Every Power 4 game since 2019, graded for both teams on five things. Tap any heading below for the full rule.

1

Beat the spread

Final margin against Vegas's closing line. Did they beat expectations?

2

Finishing

Did the scoreboard match the yardage, or did drives die?

3

Knife twist

Once up 9+, did the lead keep growing?

4

Cash-in

Points on the drive right after a defensive stop.

5

Answers

When the other team makes it a one-score game, do they score right back?

Then: garbage time is thrown out, tougher settings raise the grade, and every team's season grade is the average of its games.

Big Games

Each game gets a stage score, the same for both teams except where noted: ranked opponent +15 (top 10 +25), ranked vs. ranked +10, rivalry +20 (traditional rivalries only, like the Iron Bowl, Red River or The Game), national TV (ABC, CBS, NBC, FOX, ESPN) +10, primetime on national TV +10 more, bowl, playoff or title game +30, neutral-site showcase +20, non-conference Power 4 matchup +10, packed stadium (90%+ of its biggest crowd, night crowds count 1.25×) +10, and an opponent that won 10+ games the season before +10. 25 or more is a big game, so it takes at least two of those. Against a team outside the Power 4, it only counts if that team is ranked or it's a bowl, playoff or title game: a night game on TV against an unranked Group of 5 or FCS team isn't a test, no matter how loud it gets. Contenders in big conferences play more of them, and that's intended.

Garbage time is out

Only competitive plays count. A play is garbage time when the lead before it is more than 38 in the 2nd quarter, 28 in the 3rd or 22 in the 4th. If the lead shrinks back under the line, plays count again, so a collapse still shows up.

vs spread

Did they beat the expectation set before kickoff? Home field is already priced in.

margin (no garbage time) + closing line
Finishing

Did the scoreboard match the yardage? Out-gaining a team and losing is a finishing gap.

margin − the margin those yards usually produce
Knife twist

Once up 9 or more, does the lead grow? Net points from that moment until garbage time, compared with what's normal for that matchup.

Cash-in

Points on the very next drive after the defense gets a stop or a takeaway, compared with what's normal for a team favored by that much. The national average is about 45% of those drives scoring.

Answers

When the opponent scores to make it a one-score game, how often does the next drive score?

The game grade

Each part is scored by how rare it is compared with every Power 4 game since 2019, so there's no ceiling: a 30-point cover counts for more than a 14-point one. Answers rests on a handful of drives, so it counts half as much as the other four. A game needs at least three of the five parts. The scale: 0 is a game played exactly like Vegas expected; +5 is better than 84% of every Power 4 performance since 2019 (about 6,100 of them), and +10 is better than 96%.

average of the five parts × setting
Setting

Bigger stages magnify the grade, good or bad: road +10%, night +5%, full road stadium (90%+, night crowds count 1.25×) +10%, ranked opponent +10% (top 10 +20%), postseason +10%. A good grade against a Group of 5 team shrinks 15%, against an FCS team 40%; a bad grade against them is never softened.

Season DAWG and big games vs. routine

A season's DAWG is the average of its game grades, with 0 as an average Power 4 team. +3 or better is Dawg, −3 or worse is Soft. Big-game and routine averages leave out the setting boost, so a team doesn't look like it rose just because the stage was bigger. With only a game or two, those averages are nudged toward the team's overall number so one game can't put a team at the edge of the chart.

big games vs. routine = big-game grade − routine grade
Luck

Wins minus the wins a team's play earned. Each game's win chance comes from the play-by-play with garbage time removed: how often plays succeeded, explosive plays, penalties, turnovers forced and given away, and field-goal tries judged by distance. The parts that are mostly chance (who falls on a fumble, interception swings, missed kicks, return touchdowns) are left out, so they show up as luck. +2 means two more wins than the play earned. Lucky teams tend to come back to earth.

Data: ESPN box scores, drive logs and closing lines (ESPN BET and DraftKings) for every game involving a current Power 4 team or Notre Dame since 2019, including bowls and playoffs. Coaches from Wikipedia's list of current FBS coaches. Attendance is missing for some games; those use a 75% default.

Check the work: download every graded game (CSV, one row per team per game, with each part of the grade). It's updated every Sunday with the site.

Does It Hold Up?

If grit is a trait, a team's grade should carry over: good this year, good next year. If it's mostly luck, it should reset. Each number below runs from 0 (no carryover at all) to 1 (perfect). For reference, how good a team is carries over at about 0.5.

Which Habits Stick

Each team page shows five habits. These are the ones that carry over from one season to the next; the grade itself mostly doesn't.

What made the cut, and what didn't

Carryover is how closely a habit one year matches the next: 0 is not at all, 1 is perfectly. For reference, how good a team is carries over at about 0.5. "Predicts" is whether the habit told us anything about next season's results.

TraitCarryover 2021–24Checked on 2025Same coachPredicts next seasonVerdict

Questions You'll Ask

Why isn't my unbeaten team ranked higher?

The rank isn't about wins. It's how a team has played compared with what was expected of it. A 5–0 team that was supposed to win big and keeps winning close can rank below a 3–1 team that keeps beating expectations. Records still matter for the playoff. This measures something different: who's showing up.

Is this a betting tool?

No. The grade describes games after they happen. We tested it: a team's season grade barely carries into the next season, and picking teams by their grades went about 50/50 against the spread, the same as a coin flip. The details are in "Does It Hold Up?" above.

Why does a win sometimes grade negative?

Because the grade compares against expectations. A team favored by 20 that wins by 10 didn't do what it was supposed to, and the grade says so. Same the other way: a 7-point loss as a 20-point underdog can grade well.

Does the formula change during the season?

No. It's locked for the season, except for fixes to definitions, which are listed below with dates so nothing changes quietly.

Changes

© 2026 DAWG Index · dawgindex.com